Changes in Accounting Principle
APB Opinion No. 20

7 Change in Accounting Principle--results from adoption of a generally accepted accounting principle different from the one used previously.
8 Concerns a choice from among two or more generally accepted accounting principles. Initial adoption of a principle is not a change.
14 Views on a change in Principle.
a. Accounting principles should be applied consistently for all periods presented in comparative financial statements. If not, misinterpretation of earnings trends and other analytical data may occur. Where a change in principle occurs, prior period financial statements should be restated when presented in current reports for comparative purposes.
b. Restating financial statements of prior periods may dilute public confidence in financial statements and may confuse those who use them. Financial statements of prior periods prepared on the basis of generally accepted accounting principles at that time should be considered final.
c.  Restatement may be difficult and at times impossible.
d.  Restatement may require assumptions that furnish results different from what they would have been had the newly adopted been used in prior periods.
15 Justification for a Change in Accounting Principle -- General presumption - An accounting principle once adopted should not be changed. Consistent use enhances utility of financial statements by facilitating analysis.
16 General presumption may be overcome only if the enterprise justifies the use of an alternative acceptable accounting principle on the basis that it is preferable.
17 General Disclosure for a Change in Accounting Principle 
(a) Nature and justification for the change.
(b)  Effect on income.
19 Reporting a Change in Accounting Principle - General Rule -- 
Income before extraordinary items and net income for the period of change should be reported on the basis of the newly adopted accounting principle
(a) Financial statements of prior periods included for comparative purposes should be presented as previously reported.
(b) Report cumulative effect of the change in income of the current period in a manner similar to an extraordinary item (between captions extraordinary items and net income).
(c)  Effect of adopting the new accounting principle on income before extraordinary items and net income (and EPS amounts) of the period of change should be disclosed.
(d) Pro Forma (as if) presentations for income before extraordinary items and net income and per share amounts (basic and diluted, as appropriate under FASB Statement No. 128, Earnings per Share) should be shown on face of the income statements for all periods presented as if the newly adopted principle had been applied during all periods affected.
20  Cumulative effect-the difference between (a) the amount of retained earnings at the beginning of the period of change and (b) the amount of retained earnings that would have been reported at that date if the newly adopted principle had ben applied retroactively for all prior periods which would have been affected...

The cumulative effect should be shown in the income statement between the captions "extraordinary items" and "net income."

The cumulative effect is not an extraordinary item, but should be reported in a manner similar to an extraordinary item. 

Presentation of per-share amounts for the cumulative effect of an accounting change shall be made either on the face of the income statement or in the related notes. (amended by FAS No. 128)

27 Special Changes in Accounting Principle--

Applied retroactively - Prior period financial statements are restated to reflect the newly adopted principle.

Items requiring retroactive treatment -

(a) A change from LIFO method of inventory pricing to some other method.
(b)  A change in method of accounting forlong-term construction contracts.
(c)  A change to or from the "full cost" method of accounting in the extractive industries.
28 Nature and justification for a change applied retroactively should be disclosed in the financial statements for the period in which the change was adopted. The effect of the change on income before extraordinary items, net income and related per share amounts should be disclosed for all periods presented. 


This Summary does not substitute for reading the Original Document!!

Text of Harvey Kapnick's speech concerning Accounting Changes

************

 return to topical outline

Return to Contemporary Accounting Issues